Points of Focus
- A UK judge held Chinese law governs victims’ claims to the 61,000 seized Bitcoin.
- The ruling does not decide whether any victim holds any of the 61,000 BTC.
- The coins are worth about £3.8 billion, compared with about £700 million in net victim payments.
The UK High Court ruled on Oct. 12 that Chinese law, not English law, governs the property issues in claims by alleged fraud victims for more than 61,000 seized Bitcoin (BTC), worth about £3.8 billion. Justice Sir Mark Turner’s judgment in Director of Public Prosecutions v. Zhimin Qian is a preliminary ruling and does not decide whether any victim holds any of the coins.
UK chances of keeping £3.8bn bitcoin haul rise after High Court ruling https://t.co/ZOCT4v4oNw
— Financial Times (@FT) October 13, 2026
The Director of Public Prosecutions began civil recovery proceedings under the Proceeds of Crime Act on Sept. 18, 2024, the CPS said. Victims asserting a proprietary interest apply under section 281 of the act, and the judge heard argument on the applicable law over July 7-9.
UK High Court applies Chinese law to seized Bitcoin claims
The judge found the result is the same under Rome I, Rome II, or the common law rules of private international law, and he rejected the victims’ argument that English law applies by default until Chinese law is proved. He wrote that “the applicable law is Chinese law,” and he left the content of that law to a later stage.
What the Qian Bitcoin ruling leaves undecided
The judgment does not say who receives the Bitcoin or any surplus, and it gives no sterling value for the coins. Caixin Global reports the ruling could limit about 16,000 victims to principal and interest, a reading the judgment text does not state.
The CPS puts the number of victims above 128,000, while a February 2026 order named 2,594 section 281 applicants.
Value of the 61,000 seized BTC against victim losses
The agreed assumed facts, which the court used for this issue and did not find, say victims paid about 40.2 billion Chinese renminbi (£4.1 billion), and some received about 34.1 billion renminbi (£3.4 billion) back as purported returns from 2014 to 2017. That leaves about £700 million, though not every victim was repaid, and the Bitcoin is worth about 5.4 times that figure.
The valuation uses a Binance close of $81,850 on Oct. 12 and a European Central Bank rate of $1.3235 per pound. Bitcoin traded near $83,920 earlier that day, and the CPS valued the seizure at about £300 million at the time.
UK’s seized Bitcoin policy and the sell-or-hold question
The Home Office told Parliament on Jan. 22, 2025, that “the Government does not hold any cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin.” A petition for a strategic digital assets reserve closed on Nov. 2, 2025, with 1,063 signatures. The US barred sales of reserve Bitcoin in a March 6, 2025, order that also lists exceptions for returning assets to crime victims.
White hats moved about 52 BTC from July’s Coldcard exploit into a trust that will verify owners before returning funds. Tether froze 39.27 million USDt (USDT) on Sept. 8, froze $10 million tied to the Ledger-linked thefts, and faces a lawsuit over a separate $42.4-million freeze.
CertiK counted $2.69 billion stolen in 2026 as of Oct. 2.
Unlock premium content
Create a free account to continue reading AlphaClub articles and access exclusive features.
Share


