preferred on
Points of Focus
- The CLARITY Act failed its Senate procedural test by 49 votes to 50, well short of the 60 needed to advance.
- Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse blamed Democratic opposition and said a post-mortem is needed to understand why the bill failed.
- XRP fell as much as 10% as crypto markets reacted to the vote, while the industry now turns to the SEC and CFTC for regulatory progress.
Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse has blamed Democrats for the failure of the CLARITY Act after the landmark crypto market structure bill fell well short of the votes needed to advance in the US Senate.
Senators voted 49-50 on Tuesday against invoking cloture on the motion to proceed with the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act. The procedural motion required 60 votes, meaning the legislation never reached the next stage of Senate debate. Three Republicans, Susan Collins, Josh Hawley and Jerry Moran, also voted against advancing the measure.
Eric Balchunas said the CLARITY Act is dead for now and warned that voting against crypto could carry political consequences in November, with 15 of the 50 “no” voters up for election.
Clarity dead. 50 no votes. Immediately thought og this Bloomberg piece about how crypto supported candidates went 48 for 48 last election (which incl Ds, Rs, incumbents, challengers, shoo-ins, longshots). Personally, I wouldn't piss them off them, but hey, you got to do what you… https://t.co/Ombjh90Cdw pic.twitter.com/SD46AtOLeJ
— Eric Balchunas (@EricBalchunas) September 15, 2026
The defeat came despite a frantic final round of negotiations that produced 126 changes requested by Democrats. The latest draft strengthened ethics restrictions, expanded the role of state attorneys general and gave the Treasury additional powers to respond to stablecoin-driven deposit flight.
Garlinghouse, however, said the compromises should have been enough.
“This one stings,” he wrote after the vote, saying Ripple and much of the crypto industry had spent months trying to get the legislation across the finish line.
He said the bill was bigger than Ripple and accused Democrats of putting politics ahead of policy, referring to opponents as an “anti-crypto army.”
“A post mortem needs to be done on why this failed,” Garlinghouse said.
Ethics and Stablecoin Fight Sank CLARITY Push
The final negotiations had increasingly moved beyond the SEC-versus-CFTC jurisdictional debate that originally defined the CLARITY Act.
Democrats continued to demand tougher ethics safeguards related to President Donald Trump’s crypto interests, even after Trump agreed to additional restrictions. Critics argued that the revised measures did not go far enough to address potential conflicts of interest.
Opposition also came from outside Congress. Eighteen state attorneys general warned that the legislation could weaken states’ ability to pursue crypto fraud and investor-protection cases.
Banking groups separately pushed back against the bill’s treatment of stablecoin rewards, arguing that its proposed deposit-flight “circuit breaker” would intervene only after significant deposits had already left banks.
Senate Republicans Release Revised Clarity Act Text, Calling It Their “Final Offer” to Democrats
Senate Republicans have released revised text of the Clarity Act, which they describe as their “last, best and final” offer to Democrats ahead of Tuesday’s cloture vote, according to… pic.twitter.com/0U0aMYh4Rt
— Wu Blockchain (@WuBlockchain) September 14, 2026
XRP Takes a Hit but Regulatory Fight Moves to SEC and CFTC
Crypto markets weakened around the failed vote, with XRP among the hardest-hit major assets. XRP fell over 10% during the selloff, while Bitcoin (BTC) dropped roughly 4% and Ether (ETH) declined more than 6%.
The legislative defeat does not mean US crypto rulemaking stops.
Garlinghouse said there was still “reason for optimism,” pointing to SEC Chair Paul Atkins and CFTC Chair Michael Selig as regulators capable of filling parts of the legislative gap.
Selig had already directed CFTC staff to explore a crypto market structure framework that could move forward if Congress failed to act. The SEC and CFTC have also issued joint guidance this year addressing how federal securities laws apply to different categories of crypto assets.
Still, agency rules are not a substitute for legislation that permanently divides authority between regulators. With the November midterms approaching and Congress running short on legislative time, Reuters reported that the CLARITY Act now has little prospect of being revived in the near term.
What Happens Next?
The failed cloture vote leaves the CLARITY Act stalled rather than formally dead. Senate leaders could try to revive the legislation if Republicans and Democrats reach another compromise, but the political calendar is now working against them. Reuters reported that the bill has little chance of returning in the near term with the November midterms approaching and Congress preparing for recess.
Any revival would likely require fresh negotiations over the issues that sank Tuesday’s vote, particularly ethics restrictions, stablecoin rewards and the balance between federal and state enforcement powers. Democrats have argued that the latest ethics provisions still do not go far enough, while Republicans have said they have already made extensive concessions.
If Congress cannot reach a deal, attention will shift toward the SEC and CFTC. Both agencies have been developing crypto rules that could address parts of the regulatory gap, including how digital assets are treated and how trading platforms operate. But agency rulemaking cannot provide the same permanent division of SEC and CFTC authority that Congress could establish through legislation.
For the CLARITY Act itself to eventually become law, the Senate would still have to advance and pass legislation, the House and Senate would need to approve identical text, and the final bill would then have to be signed by the president. Tuesday’s defeat means that process effectively goes back to the negotiating table.
Share
Most read articles
